Three Powers, Four Promises And A World Still Waiting

0

Asem Mustafa Awan

Islamabad: The first meeting of Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen has ended with shared intentions, but few immediate answers to the crises confronting the world. Held on November 19 alongside the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit, the gathering was historic in its format.

Its four-point statement addressed United Nations reform, energy supplies, international courts and nuclear risks. Yet the wars in Ukraine and Iran were absent. The meeting created an opportunity for dialogue.

The nuclear question was among the most consequential subjects discussed. The leaders reaffirmed that nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought, and said their countries would hold dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing proliferation. However, no timetable or weapons limits were announced. The expiry of the New START treaty between Washington and Moscow has left a serious gap in arms control.

China has resisted negotiations designed around the much larger American and Russian arsenals. The declaration opens a door to discussion, but establishes no safeguards.

Ukraine exposed the limits of the gathering. Trump wants to end the war, while Putin insists that Russia’s concerns must be considered. Yet Ukraine was not mentioned in the joint declaration, and no ceasefire or negotiation framework emerged.

Kyiv and its European supporters oppose any settlement made without Ukraine’s participation. Any durable settlement must involve Ukraine, address its security and respect its sovereignty. A conversation among three powerful presidents cannot substitute for that process.

The conflict involving Iran was another major omission. The war has placed regional security under pressure and raised concerns about energy routes, shipping and the wider Middle East. China depends on energy flows, Russia has regional interests, and the United States remains directly involved.

Despite these overlapping interests, the leaders announced no joint initiative to end hostilities or establish diplomacy. Iran’s absence leaves unanswered whether the three powers can use their influence to encourage restraint.

Energy cooperation, by contrast, appeared in the final statement. The leaders pledged to increase production and supply of refined petroleum products and reaffirmed the importance of stable energy flows.

The pledge could matter to economies facing volatile fuel prices, but no targets or timetable were announced. Greater supply may ease market pressure, although the effect will depend on output, trade conditions and sanctions. For importing countries, the test will be whether the promise translates into reliable supplies and predictable prices.

The call for United Nations reform was another significant part of the declaration. As permanent members of the Security Council, they have influence over an institution increasingly criticised for failing to reflect today’s realities.

Developing countries have long sought a stronger voice in international decision-making. Yet reform cannot simply mean greater freedom for powerful states. A more representative United Nations must protect smaller countries, preserve international law and ensure collective security is not managed by a handful of capitals.

The declaration’s position on international courts may prove more contentious. The leaders stressed state consent and the immunity of state officials, while warning that the International Criminal Court and similar bodies must not abuse their jurisdiction. The issue is sensitive because Putin is subject to an ICC arrest warrant over alleged war crimes connected with the deportation of Ukrainian children.

Russia rejects the court’s jurisdiction. The debate concerns the balance between state sovereignty and accountability for serious international crimes. Weakening judicial accountability could deepen concerns about unequal treatment under international law.

China’s diplomatic role also deserves attention. Hosting the meeting allowed Xi to place Beijing at the centre of a rare discussion involving the world’s three major powers. It showed China’s ability to convene rivals, but not to resolve their disputes.

Taiwan, a central source of tension between Beijing and Washington, was not addressed. Nor did the declaration resolve trade and technology disputes. Their willingness to meet should not be mistaken for agreement on the future international order.

For Washington, the gathering offered an opportunity to engage directly with two major rivals. Trump welcomed the talks, but must also reassure European and Asian allies. European leaders have stressed that their security cannot be negotiated without their participation, particularly over Ukraine. The challenge for the United States is to maintain dialogue with Beijing and Moscow without weakening confidence among longstanding partners.

The wider world will judge the summit through its practical consequences. Developing economies are vulnerable to wars, energy shocks and disrupted shipping. Countries such as Pakistan, which rely heavily on imported energy, have a direct interest in stability and predictable prices.

Lower risks of escalation, reliable supplies and functioning diplomatic channels would bring tangible benefits. But these outcomes require implementation, not declarations alone.

The Shenzhen meeting should be seen as an opening rather than a settlement. If the three governments establish regular communication, begin serious nuclear-risk negotiations, support inclusive diplomacy on Ukraine and Iran, and keep energy routes open, the declaration could acquire lasting value.

The world did not receive a peace agreement in Shenzhen. It received a statement of intentions from three leaders able to influence whether tensions rise or recede. The real test begins after the cameras are gone.

Asem Mustafa Awan has extensive reporting experience with leading national and international media organizations. He has also contributed to reference books such as the Alpine Journal and the American Alpine Journal, among other international publications.

The article is the writer’s opinion, it may or may not adhere to the organization’s editorial policy.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.