Three Leaders, One Troubled World: Is Peace Still Possible?

0

Asem Mustafa Awan

Islamabad: The planned meeting of Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen carries a weight far beyond the formal gathering of three presidents. Scheduled for November 19 on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit, it will bring together leaders whose countries possess immense military, economic and diplomatic influence

. The world will watch, not because agreement is assured, but because the cost of continued confrontation is becoming increasingly difficult to contain.

The first question is whether the meeting can establish even a modest measure of trust. Washington, Beijing and Moscow have competing interests and sharply different views of international order.

Yet direct communication among their leaders matters. At a time when suspicion can quickly become policy, a willingness to speak is itself useful. It should not, however, be mistaken for reconciliation.

Nuclear security is expected to be a central subject. The expiry of the New START treaty in February removed the last major limits on the strategic nuclear arsenals of the United States and Russia. Both possess thousands of warheads, while China’s stockpile is smaller but expanding.

Washington wants Beijing included in a future arms-control framework. China has resisted joining negotiations on terms shaped by two countries with much larger arsenals. A realistic first step would be agreement to resume structured discussions, exchange information and avoid actions that intensify mistrust.

A comprehensive treaty is unlikely to emerge from one meeting.

The conflict involving Iran is another urgent concern. The war launched by the United States and Israel has disrupted regional stability and left the Strait of Hormuz under severe pressure. The consequences extend well beyond the Middle East.

Energy supplies, shipping, insurance costs and prices are exposed to every escalation. China has a direct interest in secure energy routes, while Russia has its own strategic calculations.

If the three leaders can encourage restraint, protect commercial navigation and support a credible diplomatic channel, the meeting could produce a benefit felt far beyond the conference room.

Ukraine presents a more difficult test. Moscow wants its war and the terms of a possible settlement considered, while Kyiv fears that powerful states could discuss its future without its participation. China has been reluctant to place the conflict at the centre of the trilateral agenda, and Washington’s position has shifted between pressure and negotiation.

No durable settlement can be imposed on Ukraine from outside. Any serious progress must involve the country whose territory and people are at stake, alongside credible security arrangements and respect for sovereignty.

Trade and technology form a separate fault line. The United States and China have eased some tensions after their tariff confrontation, but disputes over advanced semiconductors, critical minerals and market access remain.

A fresh escalation would affect manufacturers, consumers and economies far from either capital. The immediate task should be to preserve dialogue, honour existing commitments and prevent commercial competition from turning into another cycle of retaliation. Economic interdependence is not a guarantee of peace, but it raises the price of conflict.

The meeting will also revive questions about who gets to shape the international order. Comparisons with the 1945 Yalta Conference are understandable, but potentially misleading.

The world today is more interconnected, and decisions affecting Ukraine, Iran, Taiwan or any other society cannot legitimately be made over the heads of those who live there. Smaller states are not pieces on a geopolitical chessboard. Their sovereignty and security must remain part of any discussion about global stability.

Each leader will arrive with a different calculation. Trump may seek a visible diplomatic achievement and a framework for nuclear talks. Xi will want to demonstrate China’s influence while avoiding commitments that constrain its choices.

Putin may value the recognition and status that a meeting with both leaders provides, as well as an opportunity to press Russia’s concerns. These ambitions may overlap in the language of stability, but they do not automatically produce common ground.

The gathering must also complement, rather than overshadow, the wider APEC process. Trade, investment, supply chains, food and energy security require cooperation among many countries. Global problems cannot be settled by a small circle of leaders, however powerful they may be.

That is why expectations should remain measured. A photograph of three leaders cannot end wars, reopen trade routes or rebuild arms-control arrangements.

Nor should the gathering be judged only by whether it produces a spectacular announcement. Quiet agreements to keep communication open, reduce military miscalculation, protect shipping and continue technical negotiations could matter more than a dramatic declaration.

If all goes well, the outcome need not be a new world order drafted by three capitals. It could be something more practical and valuable: a pause in escalation, renewed nuclear dialogue, support for diplomacy over Iran, respect for Ukraine’s place in any settlement, and a commitment to manage economic rivalry without threatening global stability. None would solve every crisis. Together, however, they could create room for others to pursue peace.

The world does not need three leaders to agree on everything. It needs them to recognise that disagreement carries responsibilities, and that power is measured not only by the ability to confront rivals but by the wisdom to prevent catastrophe. In Shenzhen, even a small step away from confrontation would be worth taking.

Asem Mustafa Awan has extensive reporting experience with leading national and international media organizations. He has also contributed to reference books such as the Alpine Journal and the American Alpine Journal, among other international publications.

The article is the writer’s opinion, it may or may not adhere to the organization’s editorial policy.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.