Fix the System Before Dividing Pakistan’s Map

0

Mohammed Ajeeb

Bradford: A few weeks ago, Pakistan’s Interior Minister, Mohsin Naqvi, made a remarkable admission. A man widely known as a close friend and ally of the Establishment publicly declared that the country’s system of governance had totally collapsed. It urgently needed to be rejuvenated.

Two days ago, he offered his remedy. The country should be divided, he said, from its present four or five units into twenty new administrative units. 

The creation of more provinces, he argued, would reset the system and make it more effective, efficient and convenient for the people. 

He urged all political parties to agree to a national referendum to ascertain the views of the populace.

According to press and electronic media reports, Naqvi is presenting this as the policy of the Establishment. But if the intention was to build consensus, the response so far suggests the opposite.

Despite his recent meeting with President Asif Ali Zardari in Nawabshah, Zardari is understood to remain committed to the earlier decision of the Sindh Assembly not to create any new provinces in Sindh. 

He knows, as does his Pakistan Peoples Party, that if Karachi were annexed to a new province, it could spell the demise of the party in its strongest base.

The Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N), which controls the centre and the largest province, Punjab, also does not appear totally happy with a hasty process, particularly one led by Naqvi. 

The main opposition party, the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), led by Imran Khan from jail, despite the release of two of his sisters from prison, remains doubtful and reluctant to support the initiative in its present form. The Jamiat Ulema-e-Islam (JUI-F) of Maulana Fazlur Rehman is already under the wrath of the Establishment.

The situation, therefore, does not augur well for the easy acceptance of Naqvi’s proposal, even with the blessings of the Establishment, by a majority of political parties.

In reality, the fundamental problems that have confronted Pakistan since its very inception have little to do with the number of provinces. 

They are maladministration, rampant corruption, and the colossal revenue cost of supporting and protecting an unnecessary, unqualified and untrained civil service.

Above all, there is the unaffordable and unaccountable cost of maintaining government itself, the failure to develop a system compatible with an evolving economy, and the practice of unscrutinised budgets for development and defence. 

Buried under inflated, heavy debts and their misuse and abuse, Pakistan has been brought to the brink of liquidation.

The final blow to its long inertia and increasing political instability has been dealt by successive civil and military governments refusing to share and devolve power to local communities, to promote democracy and to lessen dependency on an unacceptable centre of power.

Until and unless necessary reforms are carried out in these essential areas – the eradication of epidemic corruption and the fair distribution of power and resources – the creation of new provinces will not be a reset. It will result in heavier financial cost, more nepotism, and further ethnic differences.

Pakistan does not need more provinces to administer the same broken system. It needs a system worth administering.

The author is former Lord Mayor of Bradford UK.

The article is the writer’s opinion, it may or may not adhere to the organization’s editorial policy.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.