Ibrar Shahid Quits Pakistan Idol, Alleges Autotuning Abuse
News Desk
Islamabad: Pakistan Idol has been thrust into controversy after contestant Ibrar Shahid abruptly quit the competition, alleging unfair treatment and excessive manipulation of his performances.
Shahid, a National College of Arts student, said he walked out during the December 9 shoot and documented his departure on video. He claimed his frustration peaked after the show uploaded his latest performance, which he said sounded “heavily autotuned” and unrecognisable.
“My voice is mine. My truth belongs to me,” he wrote, alleging the production altered his vocals to the point that they no longer reflected his real singing. He said he commented under the video to clarify the issue, but was immediately asked by the team to delete his remarks.
Read More: https://thepenpk.com/dg-khans-nabeel-makes-it-to-pakistan-idol-top-16/
According to Shahid, the pressure to stay silent and what he described as a discouraging environment ultimately convinced him to withdraw. He claimed he felt sidelined throughout the competition and was warned that speaking publicly could trigger legal consequences.
Shahid further alleged that backstage experiences differed sharply from the polished version presented to viewers, claiming that dramatic moments were shaped for effect, not authenticity. He said the behaviour he encountered harmed his confidence and disappointed supporters, including his teachers and classmates.
While acknowledging that quitting may affect his future career, he said remaining silent felt “dishonest.”
In response, the Pakistan Idol team said Shahid left voluntarily and reaffirmed that the show strictly follows international guidelines set by Fremantle, the global owner of the Idol franchise. They stated that auditions, mentoring procedures, and broadcast edits adhere to transparent, fair, and well-established standards.
The production maintained that the environment remains “stable, respectful, and well managed,” and noted that the matter is being pursued through “appropriate legal channels” to protect the show’s reputation.
Shahid’s claims have divided fans online, with some praising his courage and others questioning his accusations. Meanwhile, Pakistan Idol says the competition will proceed as scheduled, with remaining contestants moving into the next episode.
Comments are closed.